[Already said a lot of this here...but there's more.]I was very excited about Where the Wild Things Are when it came out. I had waited a long time for it, and felt it met my high expectations. Since that first viewing, however, there have been plenty of people, professional critics and personal friends alike, who have expressed their dislike for the film.
I finally got my chance to watch it a second time last night. Two things happened: 1) I was reminded why I felt it was so powerful the first time I watched and 2) I realized just how quirky it was and why not everyone would like it.
Yes, it's a melancholy movie. Now, as one who is often nicknamed Eeyore, I know I'm a bit biased. But I feel pretty strongly that any movie accurately portraying this world is going to feel melancholy. If it doesn't, it's not being truthful, at least not completely. There is a problem in this fallen world and every human is feeling it whether they acknowledge it or not. Usually problems, especially cosmic ones, are melancholic ordeals, no?
And that's precisely why I love Wild Things. It captures the essence of the human condition, showing that it starts as a child and never really goes away. We simultaneously want a King and refuse a King, and to make it even more confusing, we want to be the King ourselves. Making sense of this is not easy, and it leads towards all sorts of selfishness, insecurity, hurt, loneliness, and sadness.
So when the Wild Things ask...
"So, you were their king...and you made everything right?"
"Well, you know, what about loneliness?"
"What he's saying is, will you keep out all the sadness?"...I hear centuries of Old Testament wanderings and waitings. Eager and weary expectation. And I hear the hurt and pain and wanderings of every human heart even today. The human condition. Harassed and helpless, like sheep without a shepherd.
Max's promise is bold:
"I have a sadness shield, it keeps out all the sadness. It's big enough for all of us. And I can demolish loneliness."When one Wild Thing objects,
"I don't understand. He doesn't look like a king," I hear the words of Isaiah: "nothing in his appearance that we should desire him."
All this to say, Wild Things comes so close in so vividly showing the problem, our deepest desires. It points to a king that can keep out sadness and demolish loneliness, even though it's a king that doesn't meet worldly standards. But when this king turns out to be a farce and everything is just as lonely and sad and dysfunctional as before, the Wild Things conclude:
"There's no such thing as a King."What's the answer, then? Is that it?
Perhaps simply denial and repression, like when Carol brushes off Max's concern about the sun dying:
"That can't happen. You're the king, and look at me...I'm big. How could guys like us worry about a tiny thing like the sun?" That sounds familiar enough.
Maurice Sendak's answer--obsessed with the resiliency of children--might just be survival. It's all a mess, but we manage to survive anyway. (In answering about the suitability of the film for kids, he answers, "I saw the most horrendous movies that were unfit for child's eyes. So what? I managed to survive.")
If those are the answers, no wonder it's a melancholy film. But isn't there more? Another answer? Isn't there a King that
can take care of loneliness and sadness? A countercultural King that doesn't fit the world's standards? A King we have an awfully hard time submitting to sometimes?
Now that I'm a father since seeing the movie the first time, it all rings even more true. When I give my son instruction, I see a tension in his eyes, not knowing if he wants to obey or not. Each time it seems to be a painful decision for him, he pauses, looks me in the eye, then looks away, as though he's saying, "I want a father, but I really wish I could do whatever I want."
I have to believe that an important part of parenting is creating a small version of the kingdom we all want. This is partly what Max was looking for and missing. Parents being kings that in some small way help with the problems of sadness and loneliness and provide the safety and structure we've always wanted in the fort of our dreams. And in so doing, moms and dads point to a greater King and a greater Kingdom.
Does answering to a King--be it a parent or God himself--take away the fun of being a Wild Thing? No--there's still plenty of room for adventure and rumpuses. But these adventures and rumpuses aren't self-serving, which end up making them a lot more fun. If you're careful, you can even have a dirt-clod fight without hurting everyone's feelings.